A guide to choosing the best sugars, syrups, and sweeteners for you
A guide to choosing the best sugars, syrups, and sweeteners for you
The 1st WhatSugar–approved sweetener is HERE!
ALLULOSE
2025 BUYING GUIDE
On my quest to discover all the allulose sweeteners sold on store shelves, I found 40 products. Often called "the real sugar without the calories" or "the sugar-free sugar," allulose is a game-changer. Below, you'll find the complete list of allulose sweeteners and how they compare. [Don't miss the section at the bottom for other sugars that behave like allulose, like kabocha extract!]
CURATED JUST FOR YOU
We’ve analyzed countless sweeteners to create the WhatSugar guides, and the "Try It" button makes it easy to shop on Amazon. But if you want sweeteners carefully selected for exceptional quality and certified organic, shop WhatSugar The Sweetener Co.—our curated selection. By choosing us, you support a trusted, USA-based small business.
PURE ALLULOSE
PURE ALLULOSE UNCOVERED
Have you ever heard of allulose—a rare sugar that is mildly sweet and also known as D-psicose? If not, you’re not alone. Allulose is a relatively new sweetener on the market that has been getting lots of buzz for its culinary benefits and natural origin. But what is it, exactly? Is it truly natural? Let's take a closer look at allulose and answer all your questions.
-
Is allulose a natural sweetener?
Allulose can be considered "natural" because it exists in nature AND is made from a source material also found in nature like corn or sugar beets. However, technically, it's a synthetic sweetener — or as the FDA puts it, a natural sweetener "manufactured artificially". Allulose is found in raisins, figs, kiwi, brown sugar, molasses, wheat, and maple syrup, but only in minuscule amounts.
So, the store-bought allulose is not extracted from those natural sources. Instead, to be produced on an industrial scale, it's synthetically made from corn or other inexpensive sources of fructose, such as beet sugar. As previously discussed HERE and HERE, synthetic sweeteners can be called "natural". Note that as of January 2025, allulose is a banned sweetener in some of the top natural & organic foods grocery stores in America, such as Whole Foods Market.
-
How is allulose made?
Most products in stores are made in China from corn. Put simply, the process of making allulose involves four steps: (1) starch is isolated from corn; (2) starch is split into glucose in a process called hydrolysis; (3) glucose is converted into fructose by enzymes in a process called isomerization; (4) fructose turns into allulose using enzymes from genetically engineered microbes.
Allulose made in China is from non-GMO corn. Truvía is made in the USA from GMO-corn. One brand is imported from Germany from non-GMO sugar beets.
Be cautious of misleading claims:
Some brands falsely claim their allulose comes from figs, raisins, or jackfruit such as THIS and THIS. In reality, commercial allulose is is not extracted directly from these fruits.
Looking for more details on how allulose is made?
Refer to each GRAS notice submitted by the manufacturer for FDA review HERE —for each one, click "D-psicose" on the "Substance" column, and then download the PDF.
-
How sweet is allulose? Does allulose have an aftertaste?
Pure allulose tastes almost identical to table sugar, offering no aftertaste but less sweetness. It's 70 percent as sweet as table sugar, so you'll need to use about 1/3 more to maintain the sweetness level. You can typically use the same amount as table sugar to achieve desired results in your recipes, but they will be less sweet. Because of allulose's mild sweetness, you'll often find it blended with high-intensity sweeteners such as monk fruit and stevia. Keep scrolling down to see the allulose blends infographics.​
-
What's the difference between granulated vs crystallized vs powdered allulose? Chemically speaking, there is no difference. They differ by the size of the crystals. Crystallized allulose usually has the same fineness as granulated allulose. Granulated allulose crystals are slightly smaller than table sugar but larger than powdered sugar. Powdered allulose, as the name implies, looks a lot like powdered sugar as it has smaller crystals than granulated allulose. Since it dissolves more easily, it gives a smooth texture to icing, glazes, frosting, fillings, and sauces.​
​
Confused with ALL the info out there, not knowing who to trust or where to start when swapping sugar in your recipes or drinks?
I created a resource called Sugar Swap Starter Kit to help you with that. You'll learn everything you need to know about allulose. Our kit is specifically designed for home cooks who want to understand how different sugar alternatives stack up, find the best ones, and get tips to use them. You don't need to go through trial and error with different sweeteners, wasting time, pricey ingredients, and not to mention ruined recipes. This kit offers a quick way to get all your questions answered in one place.
ALLULOSE 101
-
Is allulose better for you than sugar?
Get this: Allulose meets the chemical definition of a sugar, just like sucrose, glucose, and fructose. It shares the same chemical formula as fructose and glucose, but its atoms are arranged slightly differently, which makes it behave very differently in our bodies. Allulose, much like fructose and glucose, is completely absorbed in the small intestine.
However, unlike traditional sugars, it isn't significantly metabolized, providing just 5 to 10% of their calories. To compare calories per gram — it's 0.4 for allulose versus 4 for table sugar. As opposed to common sugars, it's not associated with an increased risk of dental cavities, weight gain, obesity, and other chronic diseases.
-
Is allulose a zero-calorie sweetener? How many calories in it?
Technically, allulose isn't really zero-calorie like high-intensity sweeteners (sucralose, aspartame, stevia, monk fruit). But by law, it can be labeled as such because it provides a small amount of calories — less the 5 — per serving, which can be rounded to zero.
Allulose actual amount: 0.4 cal/gram = 1.5 cal/tsp = 70 cal/cup.
Table sugar (sucrose): 4 cal/gram = 15 cal/teaspoon = 770 cal/cup.
-
What's the glycemic index of allulose? What about net carbs?
Allulose has zero glycemic index and zero net carbs. Most of the allulose we ingest is excreted in urine and does not impact blood glucose or insulin levels. Since 2019, the FDA allows allulose to be excluded from "total sugars" and "added sugars" on nutrition facts labels, and enables products to carry the "no added sugar" claim.
If you're tracking your carb intake, here's what you need to know. Allulose is technically a carbohydrate and counts towards the "total carbohydrates" on the nutrition facts label. However, because it’s not digested or converted into glucose, it has zero net carbs. Net carbs means digestible carbs that break down into glucose and so, raise blood sugar levels.​
-
Does allulose affect hunger hormones?
My inbox has been flooded with questions about a 2024 rat study claiming that allulose can boost GLP-1 (glucagon-like peptide-1), a hormone that helps control hunger and reduce impulsive eating. While the study suggests promising effects of allulose, it's important to approach these findings with caution, given the significant conflicts of interest disclosed by the authors.
I’m digging deeper into this study for a comprehensive blog post, similar to the one I wrote about erythritol. Stay tuned—I'll share all the details and insights when it’s published in January 2025.
-
How to use allulose?
Touted as the perfect sweetener, allulose delivers the culinary benefits of regular sugar with fewer calories. It browns, looks, and dissolves like table sugar. It offers bulk (body & weight) to recipes and so, called a bulk sweetener. As said before, you can typically use the same amount as table sugar to achieve desired results in your recipes, but they will be less sweet. In baking, allulose makes a great substitute for table sugar, resulting in soft, moist baked goods—but don’t expect crispy textures.
Excited by all the benefits? Great! What's not to love? Scroll down to "What Are the Disadvantages of Allulose?" to find out. For practical tips on using allulose in your everyday recipes—like cookies, ice cream, bars, cheesecake, and more—check out my Sugar Swap Starter Kit.
-
Where can I buy certified organic allulose? Is it worth it?
Organic sweeteners must be processed, handled, and packaged according to a long list of strict rules set by the U.S. Department of Agriculture—the National Organic Program (NOP). These include being sourced from plants grown on farms using practices that maintain or enhance the soil and water quality while conserving wetlands, woodlands, and wildlife—among many other requirements. So, is it worth it? Absolutely!
Until the summer of 2023, certified organic allulose wasn't available in stores. As one manufacturer told me, one reason was that allulose was refined using ion-exchange and absorption resin processes to filter. But ion-exchange filtration may not be used in the processing of organic foods, unless in exceptional cases. A second reason was that certified organic allulose cannot come from processes that involve genetically engineered microbes. However, in October 2023, that changed. Two companies introduced the first organic allulose: Pyure and Slender Zero.
-
What are the advantages of allulose?
Allulose has no aftertaste and provides almost zero calories per serving (one teaspoon). It offers bulk to recipes, browns, and caramelizes. It dissolves quickly (even faster than table sugar), making it perfect for drinks and cocktails. Allulose works well in recipes that require refrigeration or freezing, helping create smooth, scoopable ice cream. It does not recrystallize like erythritol.
-
What are allulose's disadvantages?
Allulose is less sweet than sugar, so to maintain the same sweetness, requires using about 1/3 more, unless you opt for the blends (see them below), which are designed to match sugar's sweetness. Additionally, allulose is significantly more expensive, costing over 10 times as much as table sugar.
Allulose browns and caramelizes faster than white sugar, so you might remove your cookies & cakes from the oven before they are fully baked OR get an overly brown baked good. It results in softer, puffier cakes and cookies. It does not crisp up your baked goods like table sugar.​ And then there's one more potential downside.
-
Digestive Issues and Misleading Certifications
Allulose is a FODMAP—an acronym for carbohydrates associated with negative gastrointestinal effects such as bloating, flatulence, diarrhea, and nausea. The Center for Science in the Public Interest has even petitioned the FDA to require a warning label for this reason.
Some allulose brands, such as this, carry a "FODMAP Friendly" certification logo, which means the product has been lab-tested by this program to have minimal levels of specific FODMAPs — fructose, fructans, galacto-oligosaccharides, sorbitol, mannitol and lactose. The key caveat, however, is that this certification does not test for allulose itself. As a result, even certified products may still cause digestive upset.
Get all the details on how to choose and use allulose by checking out my SUGAR SWAP STARTER KIT. ​Learn how allulose compares with erythritol, stevia, and monk fruit. See the do's and don'ts of allulose. Discover when to use and avoid it in cookies, ice cream, bars, cakes, and more. Worried about digestive issues? I’ve got tips to help with that, too.
ALLULOSE BLENDS
BLENDS EXPLAINED
Pure allulose has two major drawbacks: it’s expensive and less sweet than sugar. This often frustrates people who wonder, "I have to pay 10x more and still use more than sugar?!" That’s where blends come in.
Because allulose is 30% less sweet than sugar, you’d need about 1/3 more to match sugar’s sweetness. To solve this, manufacturers blend allulose with just a pinch of high-intensity sweeteners like monk fruit or stevia, which are 20 to 300 times sweeter than sugar. These blends offer a key advantage: you can measure them just like sugar, using the same one-to-one ratio with your regular kitchen tools—no extra math required!
Blending allulose with other sweeteners doesn’t just address sweetness and cost; some blends enhance its culinary performance. In my Sugar Swap Starter Kit, I go into details of the benefits of each blend, and which are best for specific needs. I even provide step-by-step instructions to make your own blend at home, helping you save money while getting optimum results.​
What's a Brown Sugar Replacement?
With Allulose
Brown sugar replacements are designed to replicate the aroma, sweetness, and texture of regular brown sugar—but with fewer calories and zero sugar. They work as one-to-one substitutes for light brown sugar in recipes.
Those blends contain allulose combined with erythritol, monk fruit, stevia, or sweet fibers (oligosaccharides or inulin). They also have a pinch of glycerin, molasses, or malt extract to help give the overall resemblance to regular brown sugars, providing moisture and allowing them to pack. Want to dive deeper? Visit my Brown Sugar Replacement page.
What's Powdered Sugar Replacement?
With Allulose
Allulose sweeteners come in various crystals sizes—granulated, crystallized, and powdered. The terms granulated and crystallized are often used interchangeably by sellers, and both typically refer to crystals resembling table sugar, making them ideal replacements for regular sugar.
On the other hand, powdered allulose, as the name suggests, is a one-to-one substitute for regular powdered sugar, with fine crystals similar to confectioners' or powdered sugar. It’s perfect for recipes that require a smooth texture or that final decorative touch. The powdered allulose below contains finely ground allulose in pure form or combined with a pinch of monk fruit and stevia extract. Want to learn more about powdered sugar replacements? Check out my detailed guide HERE.
ZERO-CALORIE SUGARS
Beyond Allulose
RARE SUGARS AS SWEETENERS
Kabocha Extract | Xylose | Allulose
Rare sugars, as the name implies, are rare in nature and typically less sweet than table sugar. Our bodies can easily break down and digest common sugars, but not rare sugars.
-
The Digestive Effects of Rare Sugars. Like sugar alcohols (polyols), rare sugars are classified as low-digestible carbohydrates. Some of the amounts we ingest pass INTACT into our large intestine, where it may be fermented by gut bacteria and may act osmotically by drawing water from the body, causing loose stools or diarrhea.
While one of their main downsides is that they can cause digestive issues, they may also act as prebiotics, promoting the growth of healthy gut bacteria — a beneficial digestive effect.​ Common side effects of having unabsorbed sweeteners entering the large intestine include bloating, cramps, flatulence, or laxation.
-
Rare sugars can be promoted as zero-calories and zero glycemic. Even though we cannot metabolize rare sugars, bacteria in the lower digestive tract can. The low caloric value attributed to rare sugars like allulose, is because microbes metabolize it, and we obtain their energy indirectly. And that's why they provide a small amount of calories, not zero; it's about 1.5 cal/teaspoon—versus 16 cal for table sugar. They don't brake down into glucose, so have no effect on blood sugar levels.
-
Besides allulose (listed first on this page), I've found sweeteners containing the following rare sugars: kabocha extract, D-xylose, and D-tagatose.
Kabocha extract is isolated from the kabocha squash, also called buttercup squash "Delica" (Curcubita maxima D.). Kabocha extract contains rare sugars such as xylose, arabinose, and rhamnose.
Xylose is made from hemicellulose and is also known as wood sugar or coconut shell powder. It's about half as sweet as sugar. I wrote about xylose on another page as it's used to produce the sweetener xylitol.
Tagatose is made from lactose, is about 90% as sweet as sugar, and provides about 30% of the calories of table sugar (1.5 cal per gram).
-
​The main disadvantage of rare sugars: Consuming them alone on an empty stomach or in large amounts can lead to adverse gastrointestinal effects.
WhatSugar is reader-supported.
When you buy through Amazon links, this site may earn an affiliate commission.
A one-woman business relying on Amazon affiliate commission to avoid ads.
The list above is not intended to endorse, advertise or recommend products.
We present this listing simply as a service to our readers.